Tensions Between Fatwa and Human Rights: A Critical Study of The Legal Controversy Surrounding Smoking in Indonesia

Authors

  • Alwy Akbar STAI Nusantara Banda Aceh
  • Mahlil Ridwan Universitas Padjajaran
  • Abd Razak Universitas Islam Negeri Ar-Raniry Banda Aceh
  • Ikramul Fauzan Universitas Islam Indonesia

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.59525/rechtsvinding.2205

Keywords:

Fatwa; Smoking Law; Human Rights; Islamic Law.

Abstract

The controversy surrounding smoking regulations in Indonesia highlights a significant tension between religious authority, individual liberty, public health protection, and the fulfillment of human rights. Divergent perspectives among Islamic organizations regarding the permissibility of smoking particularly the fatwas issued by the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) and Muhammadiyah raise critical questions concerning the jurisdictional limits of fatwas in governing societal behavior and their intersection with state legal policies. This study employs a qualitative, library-based research approach, conducting a critical analysis of academic literature, scientific journal articles, fatwa documents, statutory regulations, and human rights instruments. The findings indicate that: 1) Discrepancies in fatwas concerning smoking reflect the methodological diversity in Islamic jurisprudence when evaluating harm, public interest, and evolving medical knowledge; 2) While religious fatwas possess moral and normative authority for Muslims, they do not inherently hold the legally binding force of state legislation; 3) The right to health, protection from secondhand smoke, religious freedom, and the economic rights of tobacco farmers and workers must be situated within a framework of constitutional equilibrium; and 4) Harmonizing fatwas, health policies, and human rights necessitates a proportional, participatory, and evidence-based approach. The study concludes that smoking regulations ought to prioritize the preservation of life and social justice without marginalizing citizens' constitutional rights. Furthermore, policy implementation should be directed toward fortifying tobacco control measures, safeguarding vulnerable demographics, and empowering affected communities.

References

Achmad, D., & Thamrin, A. (2024). Anomali fatwa Majelis Ulama Indonesia dalam sistem hukum Indonesia: Telaah hukum responsif. Al-Qisthu: Jurnal Kajian Ilmu-Ilmu Hukum, 22(1), 23–42. https://doi.org/10.32694/qst.v22i1.3011

Ahsan, A., Wiyono, N. H., Amalia, N., Rusdjijati, R., Veruswati, M., Martini, S., Prabandari, Y. S., & Yuniar, A. M. (2024). Early assessment of tobacco excise sharing fund as policy for farmers’ viable alternatives in Indonesia: Case study of four municipalities in Indonesia. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 11, Article 89. https://doi.org/10.1057/s41599-023-02585-y

Akter, S., Islam, M. R., Rahman, M. M., Rouyard, T., Nsashiyi, R. S., Hossain, F., & Nakamura, R. (2023). Evaluation of population-level tobacco control interventions and health outcomes: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA Network Open, 6(7), e2322341. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.22341

Arenas Catalán, E. (2021). The human right to health: Solidarity in the era of healthcare commercialization. Edward Elgar Publishing. https://www.e-elgar.com/shop/gbp/the-human-right-to-health-9781788979641.html

Artawan Eka Putra, I. W. G., Astuti, P. A. S., Duana, I. M. K., Suarjana, I. K., Mulyawan, K. H., Kurniasari, N. M. D., Kurniati, N. M., Dewi, K. R. A., & Bam, T. S. (2022). The implementation of smoke-free workplace policy and the determinants affecting indoor smoking in Indonesia. WHO South-East Asia Journal of Public Health, 11(2), 97–101. https://doi.org/10.4103/WHO-SEAJPH.WHO-SEAJPH_178_21

Aryani, N. M., & Yusa, I. G. (2023). Discourse on human rights issues and public policy context: Prospect of Indonesia tobacco control regulation. WSEAS Transactions on Environment and Development, 19, 383–392. https://doi.org/10.37394/232015.2023.19.35

Astuti, P. A. S. (2023). Policy incoherence and unwillingness of the Indonesian government to curb its alarming tobacco epidemic. Tobacco Control, 32(4), 405–406. https://doi.org/10.1136/tc-2023-058114

Bader, R. K. (2023). Tobacco use: Approaching dependence from an ethics perspective. Addicta: The Turkish Journal on Addictions, 10(3), 253–258. https://doi.org/10.5152/ADDICTA.2023.23143

Basyar, A. B. B., & Hilal, M. (2021). Maqashid syariah: Teori dan pengembangan. Maknawi. ISBN 978-623-94271-5-3. https://bintangpusnas.perpusnas.go.id/konten/BK20712/maqashid-syariah-teori-dan-pengembangan

Bella, A., Swarnata, A., Vulovic, V., Nugroho, D., Meilissa, Y., Usman, U., & Dartanto, T. (2024). Macroeconomic impact of tobacco taxation in Indonesia. Tobacco Control, 33(Suppl. 2), S108–S114. https://doi.org/10.1136/tc-2022-057735

Berliani, T. P., Amirulloh, M., & Damian, E. (2022). Conflict on the protection of human rights related to trademark rights and public health rights: Prohibition of display of cigarette packages at point-of-sale based on Indonesia’s positive law. Jurnal Poros Hukum Padjadjaran, 4(1), 149–161. https://doi.org/10.23920/jphp.v4i1.1083

Budimansyah, D., Ruyadi, Y., Sriyono, & Kusnadi. (2021). Hak asasi manusia (HAM) (Edisi ke-2). Universitas Terbuka. ISBN 978-623-312-255-9. https://pustaka.ut.ac.id/lib/wp-content/uploads/pdfmk/PKNI431702-KDT.pdf

Creswell, J. W., & Creswell, J. D. (2023). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approaches (6th ed.). SAGE Publications. https://www.sagepub.com/shop/buy-a-book/research-design-6-270550

Dresler, C. (2023). Human rights are holistic—inclusive of a right to the provision for cessation assistance. Addiction, 118(3), 407–408. https://doi.org/10.1111/add.16017

Flor, L. S., Anderson, J. A., Ahmad, N., Aravkin, A., Carr, S., Dai, X., Gil, G. F., Hay, S. I., Malloy, M. J., McLaughlin, S. A., Mullany, E. C., Murray, C. J. L., O’Connell, E. M., Okereke, C., Sorensen, R. J. D., Whisnant, J., Zheng, P., & Gakidou, E. (2024). Health effects associated with exposure to secondhand smoke: A Burden of Proof study. Nature Medicine, 30(1), 149–167. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-023-02743-4

Jamil, M. M., & Al Qurtuby, S. (2022). Polemics on smoking among Indonesian Muslims and Islamic organizations. Contemporary Islam, 16(2–3), 379–400. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11562-022-00490-w

Kramer, E., Ahsan, A., & Rees, V. W. (2023). Policy incoherence and tobacco control in Indonesia: An analysis of the national tobacco-related policy mix. Tobacco Control, 32(4), 410–417. https://doi.org/10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2021-056633

Madnur, M., Sofyan, A., Adam, S., & Nahrowi, N. (2023). Actualization of ijtihad and fatwa in Indonesia from legal opinion to legal binding. Analisis: Jurnal Studi Keislaman, 23(2). https://doi.org/10.24042/ajsk.v23i2.18802

Majelis Ulama Indonesia. (2009). Keputusan Ijtima Ulama Komisi Fatwa se-Indonesia III tentang hukum merokok. Dokumen keputusan Ijtima Ulama Komisi Fatwa se-Indonesia III.

Majelis Tarjih dan Tajdid Pimpinan Pusat Muhammadiyah. (2010). Fatwa Nomor 6/SM/MTT/III/2010 tentang hukum merokok. https://hpt.muhammadiyah.or.id/wiki/putusan/fatwa-06-hukum-konsumsi-tembakau-merokok

Martini, S., Artanti, K. D., Hargono, A., Widati, S., Ahsan, A., & Prabandari, Y. S. (2022). Association between percentage of smokers and prevalence of smoking attributable morbidity in Indonesia: One decade after implementation of smoke-free area regulation. BMC Public Health, 22, Article 2202. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12889-022-14435-8

Meier, B. M., Raw, M., Shelley, D., Bostic, C., Gupta, A., Romeo-Stuppy, K., & Huber, L. (2023). Could international human rights obligations motivate countries to implement tobacco cessation support? Addiction, 118(3), 399–406. https://doi.org/10.1111/add.15990

Moeis, F. R., Nurhasana, R., Rahardi, F., Novitasari, D., Shellasih, N. M., et al. (2022). The Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC) and implementation of tobacco control policies: Lessons learned from Indonesia and Thailand. World Medical & Health Policy, 14(4), 750–772. https://doi.org/10.1002/wmh3.534

Murti, D. C. W., & Ratriyana, I. N. (2022). The playground of big tobacco? Discourse network analysis of the cigarette advertising debate and policy in Indonesia. Journal of Communication Inquiry. https://doi.org/10.1177/01968599211072438

Nasrullah, A. M. A. (2023). Maqashid syariah: Konsep, sejarah, dan metode. Literasi Nusantara Abadi. ISBN 978-623-114-230-6. https://penerbitlitnus.co.id/product/maqashid-syariah-konsep-sejarah-dan-metode/

Nasution, F., Gurning, F. P., Siregar, P. A., Ahsan, A., & Kusuma, D. (2022). Implementation of the smoke-free policy in Medan City, Indonesia: Compliance and challenges. International Journal of Preventive Medicine, 13, Article 30. https://doi.org/10.4103/ijpvm.IJPVM_106_20

Pofrizal, Muslih, A., & Ardilafiza. (2021). Judicial analysis on the position of legal opinion (fatwa) of Indonesian Council of Ulama’ (MUI) in statutory regulation system of Indonesia. Bengkoelen Justice: Jurnal Ilmu Hukum, 11(2). https://garuda.kemdiktisaintek.go.id/documents/detail/2431798

Pomeranz, J. L., Merrill, T. G., & Schroth, K. R. J. (2023). Public health law in practice. Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780197528501.001.0001

Peraturan Pemerintah Republik Indonesia Nomor 28 Tahun 2024 tentang Peraturan Pelaksanaan Undang-Undang Nomor 17 Tahun 2023 tentang Kesehatan. https://www.peraturan.go.id/files/pp-no-28-tahun-2024.pdf

Peters, B. U., McArthur, N., & Titus, A. (2024). Strengthening tobacco control research: Key factors impacting policy outcomes and health equity. Frontiers in Public Health, 12, Article 1501326. https://doi.org/10.3389/fpubh.2024.1501326

Republik Indonesia. (1945). Undang-Undang Dasar Negara Republik Indonesia Tahun 1945 (dalam satu naskah). Majelis Permusyawaratan Rakyat Republik Indonesia. https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Download/92288/UUD45_SatuNaskah.pdf

Republik Indonesia. (2023). Undang-Undang Nomor 17 Tahun 2023 tentang Kesehatan. https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Download/314883/UU%20Nomor%2017%20Tahun%202023.pdf

Romeo-Stuppy, K., Huber, L., Toebes, B., Yerger, V., & Senkubuge, F. (2022). Tobacco industry: A barrier to social justice. Tobacco Control, 31(2), 352–354. https://doi.org/10.1136/tobaccocontrol-2021-056572

Rosilawati, Y., Rafique, Z., & Sudiwijaya, E. (2024). Tobacco use among in-school young adolescents in Indonesia: Exploring availability, affordability, and accessibility. PLOS ONE, 19(3), e0301291. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0301291

Sahadewo, G. A., Lencucha, R., Bandara, S., Drope, J., & Witoelar, F. (2024). Assessing the level of poverty and utilization of government social programs among tobacco farmers in Indonesia. Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 26(9), 1132–1140. https://doi.org/10.1093/ntr/ntae050

Schmidt, A. T. (2022). Freedom of choice and the tobacco endgame. Bioethics, 36(1), 77–84. https://doi.org/10.1111/bioe.12967

Siregar, R. A. (2023). Hukum kesehatan. Sinar Grafika. ISBN 978-623-391-156-6. https://bintangpusnas.perpusnas.go.id/konten/BK71998/hukum-kesehatan

Silverman, D. (2024). Interpreting qualitative data (7th ed.). SAGE Publications. https://www.sagepub.com/shop/buy-a-book/interpreting-qualitative-data-7-284014

Sugiyono. (2023). Metode penelitian kualitatif: Untuk penelitian yang bersifat eksploratif, enterpretif, interaktif dan konstruktif (Edisi ke-3). Alfabeta. ISBN 978-602-289-325-7.

Sufri, S., Nurhasanah, N., Ahsan, A., Saputra, I., Jannah, M., Yeni, C. M., Mardhiah, A., Bakri, S., & Usman, S. (2023). Barriers and opportunities for improving smoke-free area implementation in Banda Aceh city, Indonesia: A qualitative study. BMJ Open, 13(12), e072312. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2023-072312

Suteki, & Taufani, G. (2022). Metodologi penelitian hukum: Filsafat, teori dan praktik. Rajawali Pers. ISBN 978-602-425-273-1.

Tamam, A. B. (2021). Kedudukan fatwa Majelis Ulama Indonesia (MUI) dan fatwa Dewan Syariah Nasional (DSN) dalam sistem hukum Indonesia. Al-Musthofa: Journal of Sharia Economics, 4(1), 62–77. https://doi.org/10.58518/al-musthofa.v4i1.739

Toebes, B., Hartlev, M., Hendriks, A., O’Cathaoir, K., Rothmar Herrmann, J., & Sinding Aasen, H. (Eds.). (2022). Health and human rights: Global and European perspectives (2nd ed.). Intersentia.

Wiley, L. F., & Gostin, L. O. (2025). Public health law and ethics: Power, duty, restraint (4th ed.). University of California Press.

Wilkinson, T. M. (2021). Smokers’ regrets and the case for public health paternalism. Public Health Ethics, 14(1), 90–99. https://doi.org/10.1093/phe/phab002

Downloads

Published

2026-06-30

How to Cite

Akbar, A., Ridwan, M., Razak, A., & Fauzan, I. (2026). Tensions Between Fatwa and Human Rights: A Critical Study of The Legal Controversy Surrounding Smoking in Indonesia. Rechtsvinding, 4(1), 835–856. https://doi.org/10.59525/rechtsvinding.2205

Issue

Section

Articles

Similar Articles

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 > >> 

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.