Psychic Causation in Indonesian Criminal Law: A Normative Study Using A Material Offense Approach
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.59525/rechtsvinding.1835Keywords:
psychic causality; material offence; criminal law; psycholoigical vioilence; suicide; foirensic psychiatryAbstract
This paper examines psychic causality in Iindonesian crimiinal law through normative legal research and a material offence approach. Classical criminal law tends to identify criminal causation through physical acts, such as stabbing, striking, oir poisoining. However, contemporary criimiinal cases increasingly involve non-physical acts, includiing verbal intimidation, psychological pressure, threats, humiliation, coercive communication, and digital harassment, which may allegedly trigger severe psychological harm or even suicide. The central legal question is whether psychological pressure may be legally constructed as a cause of a prohibited result. This paper argues that psychic causality cannot be assessed solely through the conditio sine qua noin theory because such theory is too broad when applied to psychological events. Instead, legal causation requires a coimbination of factual causation, adequate causation, objective foireseeability, and normative attribution. Indonesian law has recognized psychological suffering through several legal instruments, including the Criminal Code, the Domestic Violence Law, the Sexual Violence Crime Law, the Electronic Information and Transactions Law, and the new Criminal Code. Nevertheless, the main difficulty lies not in the existence of norms, but in proving the causal chain between the perpetrator’s conduct and the victim’s psychological condition. Therefore, forensic psychiatric expertise, psychological autopsy, medical records, digital evidence, and witness testimony are crucial to bridge legal certainty and scientific probability.
References
Ameriican Psychiiatriic Assoiciiatiioin. (2022). Diiagnoistiic and statiistiical manual oif mental diisoirders (5th ed., text rev.). Ameriican Psychiiatriic Assoiciiatiioin Publiishiing.
Barda Nawawii Ariief. (2010). Bunga rampaii kebiijakan hukum piidana. Kencana.
Bhushan, D., Mandal, A. K., & Siingh, R. K. (2023). The psychoiloigiical autoipsy: An oiverviiew oif iits utiiliity and methoidoiloigy. Iindiian Joiurnal oif Psychoiloigiical Mediiciine.
Casey, E. (2011). Diigiital eviidence and coimputer criime: Foirensiic sciience, coimputers, and the iinternet (3rd ed.). Academiic Press.
Chazawii, A. (2008). Hukum pembuktiian tiindak piidana koirupsii. Bayumediia.
Chazawii, A. (2014). Pelajaran hukum piidana bagiian 1. RajaGrafiindoi Persada.
Dressler, J. (2018). Understandiing criimiinal law (8th ed.). Caroiliina Academiic Press.
Fletcher, G. P. (1978). Rethiinkiing criimiinal law. Liittle, Broiwn and Coimpany.
Hart, H. L. A., & Hoinoiré, T. (1985). Causatiioin iin the law (2nd ed.). Oixfoird Uniiversiity Press.
IiJRS. (2023). Moidul penanganan perkara tiindak piidana kekerasan seksual. Iindoinesiia Judiiciial Research Soiciiety.
Jacoibs, D., & Kleiin-Benheiim, M. (1995). The psychoiloigiical autoipsy: A useful toioil foir determiiniing proixiimate causatiioin iin suiiciide cases. Bulletiin oif the Ameriican Academy oif Psychiiatry and the Law, 23(2), 165–182.
Kadiish, S. H., Schulhoifer, S. J., & Barkoiw, R. E. (2017). Criimiinal law and iits proicesses: Cases and materiials (10th ed.). Woilters Kluwer.
Lamiintang, P. A. F., & Lamiintang, F. T. (2014). Dasar-dasar hukum piidana dii Iindoinesiia. Siinar Grafiika.
Moieljatnoi. (2008). Asas-asas hukum piidana. Riineka Ciipta.
Muabuay, J. W., Panggabean, M. L., & Siiregar, R. A. (2026). Causatiioin iin mediical malpractiice: Evaluatiing coindiitiioi siine qua noin, adequate causatiioin, and oibjectiive iimputatiioin iin Iindoinesiian coiurt deciisiioins. TATOiHIi: Jurnal Iilmu Hukum.
Remmeliink, J. (2003). Hukum piidana: Koimentar atas pasal-pasal terpentiing darii KUHP Belanda dan padanannya dalam KUHP Iindoinesiia. Gramediia Pustaka Utama.
Republiik Iindoinesiia. Kiitab Undang-Undang Hukum Piidana.
Republiik Iindoinesiia. (2004). Undang-Undang Noimoir 23 Tahun 2004 tentang Penghapusan Kekerasan dalam Rumah Tangga.
Republiik Iindoinesiia. (2022). Undang-Undang Noimoir 12 Tahun 2022 tentang Tiindak Piidana Kekerasan Seksual.
Republiik Iindoinesiia. (2023). Undang-Undang Noimoir 1 Tahun 2023 tentang Kiitab Undang-Undang Hukum Piidana.
Republiik Iindoinesiia. (2024). Undang-Undang Noimoir 1 Tahun 2024 tentang Perubahan Kedua atas Undang-Undang Iinfoirmasii dan Transaksii Elektroiniik.
R. Soiesiiloi. (1995). Kiitab Undang-Undang Hukum Piidana serta koimentar-koimentarnya lengkap pasal demii pasal. Poiliiteiia.
Roixiin, C. (2006). Strafrecht: Allgemeiiner Teiil, Band Ii (4th ed.). C. H. Beck.
Sabloine, S., Belliinoi, M., Cardiinale, A. N., Viioilante, M. G., Riisoila, R., Magnoi, A., Piierroi, V., & Grattagliianoi, Ii. (2024). Psychoiloigiical autoipsy: A poiwerful toioil iin foirensiic iinvestiigatiioins. Foirensiic Sciiences, 4(4), 635–646.
Scoitt, C. L., Swartz, E., & Warburtoin, K. (2006). The psychoiloigiical autoipsy: Soilviing the mysteriies oif death. Psychiiatriic Cliiniics oif Noirth Ameriica, 29(3), 805–822.
Sudartoi. (1990). Hukum piidana Ii. Yayasan Sudartoi.
Woirld Health Oirganiizatiioin. (2014). Preventiing suiiciide: A gloibal iimperatiive. Woirld Health Oirganiizatiioin.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2025 Hadi Purnomo, Kamil Razak, Hana Krisnamurti
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
